- DALI
- digital lighting bus, up to 64 control gear per line (IEC 62386)
- KNX
- open building bus for several trades (ISO/IEC 14543-3)
- Wireless
- Bluetooth Mesh, CR05 gateway for up to 100 nodes per zone (manufacturer data)
- Retrofit in existing buildings
- LED drivers with 0-10 V or DALI (system requirement)
- Data access in Germany
- common, freely configurable interface (§ 56(2) no. 2 GModG)
How do DALI, KNX, wireless and 0-10 V differ?
DALI, DALI-2 and D4i
DALI (Digital Addressable Lighting Interface) is a standardised digital lighting bus under IEC 62386. A two-wire control line addresses, groups and dims up to 64 control gear per line individually, and the drivers report their status. DALI-2 is the updated version with certification by the DiiA (Digital Illumination Interface Alliance). It also covers sensors and push buttons, improving interoperability. D4i is a DiiA certification for DALI inside the luminaire: the driver powers luminaire-mounted sensors or wireless modules and provides luminaire, energy and diagnostic data.
KNX
KNX is an open standard for building system technology under ISO/IEC 14543-3. It links lighting, shading, heating and other trades via a bus cable, or alternatively via radio or IP. Many manufacturers offer KNX devices, configured with vendor-independent software. Luminaires are integrated via switching and dimming actuators or KNX-DALI gateways.
Wireless: Bluetooth Mesh and other systems
Bluetooth Mesh is a wireless standard in which nodes relay messages, creating a meshed network without control cables. There are also wireless systems based on Zigbee or EnOcean, as well as proprietary Bluetooth-based systems. One well-known example of a Bluetooth-based system is Casambi, which many luminaire and driver manufacturers integrate. Wireless needs radio planning, as metal racking, walls and distance affect range.
0-10 V
0-10 V is an analogue dimming interface: a control voltage sets the driver's dimming level. There are no addresses and no feedback, and all drivers on one control line dim together. If the sensor sits directly on the luminaire, a short lead to its own driver is enough, and wireless handles the networking between luminaires.
How do the systems compare?
The table shows typical characteristics; much depends on products and design.
| Criterion | DALI / DALI-2 | KNX | Wireless (e.g. Bluetooth Mesh) | 0-10 V |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical use | new build, refurbishment with open ceiling | new build, full refurbishment | existing buildings, retrofit during operation | existing and new, often as interface at the luminaire |
| Cabling | control line to every control gear | bus cable to every device | no control cable, existing mains supply only | control line per group or short lead inside the luminaire |
| Cost drivers (qualitative) | cable installation, addressing, programming | design, programming, actuators, gateways | number of nodes, gateways, radio planning, commissioning | cabling per group |
| Openness, interfaces | standardised, BACnet via gateway | open standard, BACnet via gateway | protocol often proprietary, BACnet via gateway or controller | dimming signal only, no data |
| Vendor lock-in | low for control gear, control level partly proprietary | low, many manufacturers | usually tied to one system | low |
| Scalability | 64 control gear per line, multiple lines | very large via lines and areas | via zones and gateways | limited, no individual addressing |
| Data and monitoring | status feedback, energy and diagnostic data with D4i | depends on the devices | per node, depends on the system | none |
In existing buildings, cabling is usually the largest cost item of a bus system: new cables, ceiling work, interruptions. In new buildings the cable routes are open anyway, which shifts the balance towards DALI or KNX. What drives the cost in detail is explained in lighting control costs.
What does German law require of the system?
The GModG (German Building Modernisation Act, Gebäudemodernisierungsgesetz, sometimes abbreviated GMG) does not prescribe a protocol. § 56(6) requires non-residential buildings above 70 kW to have automatic lighting control by 31 December 2029, which should be appropriately zoned and include occupancy detection. The paragraph opens with "in addition to the requirements of paragraph 2" (our translation). Paragraph 2 describes what the building automation and control system must be able to do, including, in paraphrase, making the collected data accessible via a common, freely configurable interface so that analyses can be carried out independently of companies and manufacturers (§ 56(2) no. 2 GModG).
How far these requirements apply to the lighting control itself cannot be read conclusively from the wording. In practice, there is a strong case for choosing a system that passes its data on via an open interface such as BACnet. More on building automation under § 56(1).
Which system suits an existing building?
The choice mainly follows what is already in the building:
- LED luminaires with dimmable drivers, no ceiling work planned: wireless with sensors on the luminaire, dimming via 0-10 V or DALI on the existing driver.
- Existing DALI installation in good condition: keep using it, add sensors and check the connection to building automation.
- Existing KNX infrastructure: integrate lighting via actuators or KNX-DALI gateways, provided cable routes exist.
- Full refurbishment with open ceilings, or new build: wire a bus and coordinate the decision with the building automation design.
- Fluorescent lamps or non-dimmable drivers: switch to LED with dimmable drivers first, then add control.
Mixed solutions are common, such as wireless in the warehouse and DALI in a refurbished office wing, joined up via building automation. Whatever the system: form zones by use, provide occupancy detection and plan monitoring per zone, as described in zoning and occupancy detection. How to check drivers and type plates is covered in retrofitting existing luminaires.
What does a wireless retrofit look like in practice?
SensMotion retrofits existing LED lighting wirelessly. Sensors and luminaires communicate via Bluetooth Mesh, so no new control cables are needed. The sensor sits on the luminaire and dims the existing driver via 0-10 V; for DALI drivers, DALI integration is available on request. CR05 gateways connect up to 100 nodes per zone.
The wireless components come from one matched system (Keilton+autani). The data level is open, and that is what matters for monitoring and verification: the AU-Manager provides monitoring and passes occupancy and energy data to the building automation system via BACnet/IP. The solution covers lighting under § 56(6) and supplies data for building automation; HVAC automation is a separate part. The sensors are listed under products.
Frequently asked questions
Is DALI mandatory for the lighting control obligation?
No. § 56(6) GModG requires automatic lighting control with zoning and occupancy detection as the default case, but no particular protocol. DALI, KNX and wireless systems can all meet the requirements.
Can DALI and wireless be combined?
Yes. Wireless systems can drive DALI drivers via interface modules, and parts of a building with different systems can be brought together via building automation. For the wireless solution described here, DALI integration is available on request.
Is wireless reliable in halls with steel racking?
Yes, if the radio links are planned. In a mesh, nodes relay messages, but metal shortens the range. For the CR05, the manufacturer specifies planning rules: central in the zone, devices within a radius of about 30 m, no more than 4 radio hops.
What is the difference between DALI-2 and D4i?
DALI-2 is the certified evolution of the DALI standard for control gear and control devices. D4i builds on it and covers DALI inside the luminaire, with power for luminaire-mounted sensors and standardised energy and diagnostic data.
Is KNX worthwhile for lighting control in existing buildings?
Mainly if KNX infrastructure already exists or a full refurbishment is due. Retrofitting KNX just for lighting means new bus cables and programming. In existing buildings, wireless at the luminaire is usually the shorter route.
Last reviewed: 18 November 2026. General information, not legal advice. The legal text is authoritative.