Law & obligations

GModG exemption: when is lighting control unreasonable?

Updated 18 November 20266 min readSensMotion editorial team
In shortThe lighting control obligation under Section 56(6) of the GModG (German Building Modernisation Act, Gebäudemodernisierungsgesetz) only lapses where installation is technically impossible or economically unreasonable. Paraphrased, a measure is economically reasonable if the expenditure can be recovered through savings within the usual service life. For retrofitting lighting control onto existing LED luminaires this is usually the case, so the exemption rarely applies.
At a glance
Exemption
technically impossible or economically unreasonable (Section 56(1) and (6) GModG)
Benchmark
economic efficiency principle (Section 5 GModG)
Exemptions procedure
Section 102 GModG
Savings from occupancy control
24 % on average (LBNL, Williams et al., LEUKOS 2012)
Savings from combined strategies
38 % on average (LBNL, Williams et al., LEUKOS 2012)

Which exemptions does Section 56 GModG provide?

Section 56 GModG requires non-residential buildings in Germany whose heating, air-conditioning or combined system has a rated output of more than 70 kW to have building automation (paragraph 1) and automatic lighting control (paragraph 6) by 31 December 2029. Scope: see the 70 kW threshold.

Paragraphs 1 and 6 contain the same exemption. The obligation does not apply where installation is

  • technically impossible, or
  • economically unreasonable.

The benchmark for the second case is the economic efficiency principle in Section 5 GModG. Exemptions are governed by Section 102. Whether, in a specific case, the exemption applies directly under Section 56 or an exemption must be applied for under Section 102 should be checked individually. More on paragraph 6: Section 56(6) GModG.

This article is not legal advice; the statutory text is authoritative. The figures in the worked example are example assumptions, not prices or commitments.

How does the economic test work?

Paraphrased, the expenditure must be recoverable through the resulting savings within the usual service life; the precise assessment is case by case. For an initial estimate, you need four inputs:

  • Expenditure: costs of planning, sensors, installation and commissioning.
  • Savings: energy saved per year, minus the standby consumption of the sensors.
  • Energy price: to convert the kilowatt hours saved into euros.
  • Usual service life: the period within which the measure must pay for itself.

Several strategies, such as occupancy and daylight control, are multiplied rather than added: total = 1 − (1 − a) × (1 − b). With 24 % for occupancy and 28 % for daylight, the arithmetic result is around 45 %. The LBNL meta-analysis found an average of 38 % for combinations, and simulations often overestimate daylight savings. For a robust test, use the lower, measured values. The details are covered in Calculating and verifying savings.

Worked example: hall with existing LED luminaires

The following example is illustrative. All values are example assumptions, not SensMotion prices and not a statement about any real building. The calculation is static, meaning it excludes interest, price changes and running costs.

AssumptionExample value
Lighting electricity consumption before200,000 kWh per year
Electricity priceEUR 0.20 per kWh
Expenditure for planning, sensors and installationEUR 40,000
Sensor standby consumption1,000 kWh per year
Usual service life10 years
Savings rate24 % (LBNL average for occupancy control)

This gives:

  • Energy saved: 200,000 kWh × 24 % = 48,000 kWh, minus 1,000 kWh standby = 47,000 kWh per year.
  • Cost saved: 47,000 kWh × EUR 0.20 = EUR 9,400 per year.
  • Payback: EUR 40,000 ÷ EUR 9,400 = around 4.3 years.
  • Over 10 years: around EUR 94,000 saved against EUR 40,000 spent.

In this example, the measure pays for itself well within the assumed service life. How robust is the result to other savings rates?

Savings rateNet energy saved per yearCost saved per yearPayback
12 % (half the LBNL value)23,000 kWhEUR 4,600around 8.7 years
24 % (LBNL occupancy control)47,000 kWhEUR 9,400around 4.3 years
38 % (LBNL combinations)75,000 kWhEUR 15,000around 2.7 years
60 % (guide value for halls, project-dependent)119,000 kWhEUR 23,800around 1.7 years

Even with half the conservative LBNL average, payback stays within 10 years. In this example, break-even is at a savings rate of around 10.5 %. Only below that would the measure fail to pay for itself over the assumed service life.

Why does the exemption rarely apply to lighting control?

For lighting control retrofits, several factors point to a favourable ratio of expenditure to savings:

  • No new luminaires: the law requires control, not luminaire replacement. Existing LED luminaires with dimmable drivers (0-10 V or DALI) stay in service.
  • No new control cabling: with a wireless system (Bluetooth Mesh), cabling is not needed; see Retrofitting lighting control on existing luminaires.
  • Documented savings: even the conservative LBNL averages are 24 % for occupancy and 38 % for combinations.
  • High values in halls: in sparsely occupied halls and warehouses, project values are often considerably higher, with over 60 % as a guide value and up to 75 % from sensors, always project-dependent.

Margins can become tighter where lighting runs for very few hours a year or an area is constantly fully occupied. Even then, it is worth calculating per area rather than for the whole building at once.

Do not assume grant funding in the calculation. Under the German BEG EM programme, the individual measure for lighting in non-residential buildings was removed with the guideline of 20 July 2026 (valid from 21 July 2026). Details in Funding for lighting control in Germany 2026.

What does technically impossible mean?

Installation is technically impossible only if it genuinely cannot be carried out. Many common concerns can be solved technically:

  • High ceilings: according to the manufacturer, hall sensors are designed for mounting heights of 6 to 15 m.
  • No 12 V auxiliary output on the driver: for halls, there are sensors with their own power supply and relay. In offices, whether a driver replacement is needed is assessed.
  • No cable routes: wireless control needs no new control cabling.

A general reference to the existing installation is therefore unlikely to suffice. If you rely on technical impossibility, set out the reasons for each area.

Which documents do you need?

Whether you claim the exemption or fulfil the obligation, clear documentation helps, for example in acquisitions, financing or queries from authorities:

  • Evidence of the rated output of each heating, air-conditioning or combined system.
  • Survey of the existing installation: luminaires, drivers, mounting heights and operating hours per area.
  • Lighting consumption data, measured or calculated transparently, for example according to EN 15193-1 or the German DIN 18599 series.
  • Quotes or cost estimates for planning, sensors and installation.
  • The savings assumption with its source and calculation method, including standby consumption.
  • A justified assumption for the usual service life.
  • For technical impossibility: a technical statement for each area.

If you retrofit, measuring before and after over the same reference period and with the same operating hours shows the actual savings.

Frequently asked questions

When is lighting control economically unreasonable?

Paraphrased, when the expenditure cannot be recovered through savings within the usual service life. The benchmark is Section 5 GModG, and the assessment is made case by case. For retrofits onto existing LED luminaires, this is rarely the case.

Which savings rate should I assume?

Conservatively, the LBNL averages: 24 % for occupancy control and 38 % for combinations. Project values in halls are often higher but project-dependent. Several effects are multiplied, not added.

Do I need to apply for the exemption?

Exemptions are governed by Section 102 GModG. Whether the exemption applies directly under Section 56 in your case or an exemption must be applied for should be checked legally. Either way, document your reasons.

Can funding be included in the calculation?

The individual measure for lighting in non-residential buildings has been removed from the German BEG EM programme. Do not assume a grant for lighting control as a matter of course.

Is a missing AUX output a reason for the exemption?

Usually not. On its own, it does not make a retrofit technically impossible. For halls, there are sensors with their own power supply and relay; in offices, a driver replacement is assessed.

Last reviewed: 18 November 2026. General information, not legal advice. The legal text is authoritative.

Getting started

From your question to a finished plan.

Free initial consultation, one contact person.

Send a photo of the driver labelWe check free of charge whether your luminaires can be retrofitted.
Add your floor planWe turn it into a 3D model with sensors and zones.
Planning and quoteYou see the result in 3D first, then you decide.